17

posted by CoachTerrell 20d ago

Heavy slow resistance vs eccentrics, what I actually tell people

This comes up in half the threads here, so let me lay it out once. Eccentrics and Heavy Slow Resistance (HSR) both work. The data does not crown a clear winner, but here is what actually dictates success in the real world: 1. Adherence is everything. Running an HSR protocol 3 days a week for 6 months beats a twice-daily eccentric routine you abandon after 3 weeks. 2. Match the site and range. Insertional Achilles needs range limits like flat-ground calf raises rather than deep deficit drops. Patellar tendons thrive on heavy slow leg presses and hack squats. Upper body tendons take far less absolute load than people think. 3. Progress the weight. The biggest mistake in self-directed PT is staying at the same safe load from week 2 to week 12. If you do not titrate the weight up, you are just maintaining, not rebuilding tissue. 4. Manage the flare-ups. Mild soreness during the work that settles within 24 hours is fine. Sharp pain or worse baseline stiffness the next morning means you overshot your load. 5. Respect the timeline. 12 weeks is your first real evaluation mark, and 6 months is a standard cycle for full tendon remodeling. Mechanical loading is the primary driver here. Pinning BPC-157, TB-500, or GH is an adjunct to the physical work, not a shortcut around heavy reps. Load the tissue first.

You cannot inject your way out of a bad program.

6 comments

Add a comment

Sign in to join this conversation.

Dr_Rehab_RayCleveland, OH6 points20d ago
Endorsed in full. Point 4 is the biggest failure point I see in clinic. People arrive saying loading failed, but nine times out of ten they've been doing the same three sets with a light band since spring. Tendon adapts to progressive stimulus.

Load is the drug with the best data.

AchillesAnnaPortland, OR7 points19d ago
Point 3 saved me eight months too late. Full range heel drops on an insertional issue, twice daily for months, just getting worse while thinking I was broken.

Slow is smooth. Smooth is 5k pace eventually.

jumpers_knee_jessOmaha, NE7 points19d ago
Point 2 is why I switched my athletes to heavy slow resistance. Teenagers will not do twice daily eccentrics. A 20-minute session before practice twice a week actually gets done, and done beats skipped every time.

Isometrics before ice. Every time.

desk_jockey_danaRaleigh, NC3 points19d ago
Point 5 answers the question I was too embarrassed to ask. 'Settles within 24 hours' is a rule I can actually apply.

Currently typing with correct posture. Probably.

slow_healer_samBoise, ID2 points18d ago
Point 6 right there. Twelve weeks before evaluating. I have quit at least three different things at week five.

Still here. Still slow.

CoachTerrellAtlanta, GA1 points18d ago
That is the single most common reason people think nothing works for them. Week five is right in the trough where it feels completely pointless, so people switch programs right before adaptation kicks in.

You cannot inject your way out of a bad program.